Trickle Down
(ChatGPT)
Trickle-down economics refers to the theory that tax breaks and other economic benefits provided to the wealthy and businesses will eventually “trickle down” to benefit the broader population. It has been a core idea behind supply-side economic policies, particularly associated with:
- Ronald Reagan’s tax cuts in the 1980s
- George W. Bush’s tax cuts in the 2000s
- Donald Trump’s 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
🔹 Description of Trickle-Down Policies:
Key features:
- Tax reductions for the wealthy and corporations
- Deregulation to encourage investment
- Reduced government spending (except on defense)
- Belief: Wealthy individuals and businesses will invest more, expand operations, and create jobs, leading to widespread economic growth
🔹 Results and Outcomes:
1. Economic Growth:
- Short-term GDP growth has occasionally occurred following tax cuts (e.g., after Reagan and Trump tax cuts), but growth was often modest and temporary.
2. Income Inequality:
- Wealth has disproportionately gone to the top earners.
- From the 1980s to now, income inequality has sharply increased in the U.S., with top 1% income and wealth shares rising significantly.
3. Deficits and Debt:
- Tax cuts often lead to increased budget deficits, unless offset by spending cuts (which are politically difficult).
- Reagan, Bush, and Trump eras all saw rising national debt following tax cuts.
4. Job and Wage Growth:
- Empirical studies show limited evidence that tax cuts for the wealthy substantially boost job creation or wages.
- CBO, CRS, and independent economists found corporate tax cuts mainly benefited shareholders via stock buybacks, not workers.
🔹 Scholarly Consensus:
Most modern economists do not support trickle-down as an effective way to boost broad-based prosperity. A 2015 IMF study found that increasing the income share of the top 20% actually reduces economic growth, while boosting income for the bottom 20% raises it.
🔹 Summary:
| Aspect | Result |
|---|---|
| GDP Growth | Modest and often temporary |
| Income Inequality | Increased substantially |
| Budget Deficits | Grew after each major tax cut |
| Job/Wage Impact | Little evidence of broad wage or job growth benefits |
Trickle-down policies have consistently failed to deliver on their promise of widespread prosperity. The benefits have mostly been concentrated among the wealthy.
Back to Trickle Down